Count Heather Hoye of Homestead among the lucky ones when it comes to the national mortgage foreclosure crisis.
Thanks to help from Pennsylvania's new Refinance to an Affordable Loan program, Hoye and her 7-year-old son, Andre, remain in the home she could have lost when she found herself facing hundreds of dollars more in monthly payments when her adjustable rate mortgage reset at a higher interest rate.
Hoye is one of an estimated 25,000 homeowners in Pennsylvania who could face foreclosure -- potentially 5,000 in Allegheny County -- when their mortgage payments increase this year, according to some estimates. And while programs like the state's REAL initiative are helping some, experts say the number of people benefiting remains relatively small.
"We haven't been getting as many clients as I would have liked to have seen, and I attribute that to a number of factors, including clients who wait until they are facing sheriff sale or just give up, before coming in for help and it's just too late," said Dawn T. Williams, an attorney with the Urban League of Greater Pittsburgh and the league's director of housing.
She has helped to counsel about 150 homeowners.
Since the state started its REAL program Oct. 31, just 31 homeowners across the state, including five in the Pittsburgh area, have obtained new, lower-interest rate loans, costing the state about $4.1 million, said Kate Newton, director of the Pennsylvania Housing Finance Agency's Homeownership Programs. Twenty more locally are being processed.
Hoye was one of the five. She was able to have her existing loan refinanced, and she obtained a 30-year fixed-rate loan -- at 7.6 percent -- from American Financial Mortgage Corp. The loan then was purchased by the state.
"Working through the Mon Valley Initiative, and after attending counseling sessions to help me better budget my finances, I got rid of an 11.99 percent interest rate and now can afford my monthly mortgage payments," said Hoye, an employee of American General Services Corp., Downtown, a local mortgage title insurance and real estate closing company.
The REAL program combines 100 percent financing with flexible credit underwriting. It is for homeowners who may not qualify for typical mortgage refinance programs. It is funded by the state Housing Finance Agency, which has spent $4.1 million through last week.
Sometimes the efforts of local agencies to keep people in their homes don't work, even when their mortgage payments are reduced.
Shelly Davis of Penn Hills, a single mother with two teenage children, can attest to that.
Despite the Urban League of Pittsburgh's success in modifying her loan with Option One Mortgage, the final numbers still couldn't make her home affordable, she said.
"On my income of $1,088 a month, from disability payments, my mortgage payments fell from $734 to $615 a month, yet that left me with little money to pay for basic things for me and my children," she said.
Her next choice may be rental housing, which the Urban League is attempting to arrange once the mortgage company agrees to foreclose on her current home.
The foreclosure epidemic is expected to affect 1 million homeowners this year, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association of America.
With that in mind, Congress approved $180 million in funding for counseling services to homeowners nationwide facing foreclosure from problems with subprime and adjustable rate mortgages.
One local agency that is sharing those funds is the Allegheny County Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now -- better known as Acorn.
"We have counseled about 150 homeowners facing possible foreclosure action, and with the 50 other homeowners we've counseled under other programs, we have been successful in saving about 80 percent from foreclosure," said Maryellen Hayden, lead organizer for the local chapter.
The Urban League's Williams said that when Mayor Luke Ravenstahl announced a 311 mortgage crisis hotline in early March, efforts to counsel homeowners became more intense, supported by a grant from Congress.
Williams said most clients come in for help once they receive a default notice from their lender and the initial step the league takes is to qualify them for the state Housing Finance Agency's REMAP -- Homeowners' Emergency Mortgage Assistance Program. It provides homeowners with a loan to bring the mortgage up-to-date, and assistance on the monthly payment for up to 24 months.
"Our goal is to create a long-term, affordable mortgage for our clients through mortgage modification -- turning 12 percent interest rate loans into 30-year fixed-rate loans at about 6 percent ," Williams said.
Dan Sullivan, a foreclosure prevention specialist at Action-Housing, said he has counseled about 30 homeowners, one-fourth of them because they called the 311 hotline.
"We've been able to successfully get the mortgage modified or restructured for about 20 to 30 percent, but the problem we face is that too many are coming in when it's late in the foreclosure process," Sullivan said.
Homeowners have a better chance for success if they get help once they receive notice of default from their lenders, or if they are concerned they may not be able to make future payments, he said.
Lenders are becoming more agreeable to working with agencies to help homeowners modify loans, he said.
At first, the 311 calls averaged about 20 a week, said Wendy Urbanic, manager of the 311 hotline program. But over the past couple weeks, there have been no calls, she said.
"The sooner they get the counseling, the sooner they have a better chance to deal with it proactively," she said.
Calls are referred to one of seven local agencies. Besides Action-Housing and the Urban League, the others are Neighborhood Housing Services, Pittsburgh Community Reinvestment Group, Community Counseling Services of the South Side, NeighborWorks and Fair Housing Partnership of Greater Pittsburgh.
Another program being offered by the state Housing Finance Agency is called HERO -- Homeowners' Equity Recovery Opportunity. The agency purchases the existing loan from the lender, then provides up to 100 percent financing for a new 30-year fixed-rate mortgage at 7.625 percent. The state agency will own and service the new loan.
Of an initial 438 Allegheny County homeowners who inquired about the program, 99 applications are being processed and 10 have been approved, the state Housing Finance Agency's Newton said. Westmoreland homeowners had the next largest number of inquiries -- 114, with 20 being processed and two approved.
Sam Spatter can be reached at sspatter@tribweb.com.
Ron DaParma can be reached at rdaparma@tribweb.com.
Builders: Give Home Buyers a Tax CreditFifth Third to raise $2 billion capital, cut dividend